A Crisis of Roles: Understanding the Power and Purpose of Men

woman at work with baby

Olivia J. Scott, Senior Writer, Woman to Woman Blog Talk

JOIN us on FACEBOOK               Bookmark and Share

“As humorous as that may sound, our men are faced with what could be the biggest threat in the whole of their existence. It’s not the proliferation of nuclear weapons, or a possible World War III, or an inability to be a man, it’s us—women.” (womantowomansite)

Think about the following for a moment.

“Your father used to bring home the bacon, but now your wife is bringing home not only the bacon but the pig. Besides that, she owned two pigs before you married her. She doesn’t want any bacon from you; she already has bacon. If both husband and wife are now bringing home the bacon, then who’s the provider? That’s a problematic question for men. If both are paying the mortgage, then who’s putting the roof over their heads?”

Your father says, “Put her in her place.” You say, “But the place belongs to her.”

As humorous as that may sound, our men are faced with what could be the biggest threat in the whole of their existence. It’s not the proliferation of nuclear weapons, or a possible World War III, or an inability to be a man, it’s us—women.

There has long been a paradigm shift in the roles of men and women. There is heightened conflict over what really is the man’s place in society, the conflict being more palpably evident in the First institution—the family.

The Women’s Liberation Movement, and the relentless clamor for female independence, does not help the shift, and is feared by many men and anti-feminists as a dreaded threat to the world’s manhood.

“In many ways, the woman has taken over not only the man’s traditional role of provider, but also that of protector. She has mace, she has a gun in her purse, and she has a cell phone to call the police instantly. So what does the man do? He says, “I’m your protector,” and she says, “I don’t need you to protect me.”

The traditional acquisition of ideas and roles of manhood, by sons, from their fathers, has become practically extinct, since more than enough households are now matriarchal, demonstrative of the role-shifting. The man is hardly anywhere to be found!

Though pleasurably immersed in the independence they fought for, women complain bitterly of men not taking up their roles and responsibilities as fathers and husbands. But women have to ask themselves “How did we contribute to this frowned upon escape phenomenon, so evident in our neo culturalism?” Added to that eye-opening question, perhaps, a few gentle proverbial reminders that you cannot expect to “eat your cake and still have it.”

Have we in fact and in truth, by our actions and contemporary beliefs of our roles, confused men, having them doubt their manhood, their abilities, their potential for contribution, their own roles and functions, and their place in the lives of their women and children?

We call for men to be “responsible,” but we are guilty of displaying selfish double-standards by being, consciously or unconsciously, irresponsible when we present ourselves as all-capable and self-sufficient? With this attitude and approach, we defeat the roles men are ready and willing to play, even before they try. However, while a degree of solipsism may be allowed for both men and women, and while the man is inherently regarded as the head of the home, it is unnecessary to evoke a superiority-inferiority divide.

Gender equality advocates would call this “equality.” Call it what you may. Others may call it a “partnership,” two partners, one ship, one man, one woman, one head. Here is where the misconception may have started, though. Being designated “the head” of the household does not mean that men are the bosses of women, or that women are inferior to men. At some point, and in various matters, men vis-à-vis women each have functional advantages over the other. The superiority-inferiority complex has to be laid to rest, as it is the foundation for relationship and gender conflict.

A cultural twist and the cultural dilemma

Men don’t only need acceptance, they need to feel loved, respected, and valued. But “The independence of women is diminishing men’s traditional value to them.”

“In addition, since a woman’s childbearing and child rearing was what formerly brought her respect from her husband, the man now has to find another way to honor his wife. Because of the traditional patterns, when a wife demands respect from her husband today, he sometimes think, “Well, what are you doing to earn it?”

On the flip side, “Some women wonder, “How am I supposed to be submissive when I make more money than my husband, and the house and furniture are mine?” In other words, she’s saying to the man, “You have to earn the right for me to submit to you by giving me something I haven’t already given to you.” That’s a tough statement for a man to hear. So the man says, “Well, I can’t give you anything because you owned more than I did from the beginning.” How does a woman submit to somebody whom she believes she is supporting? It’s a difficult situation for both men and women. But it’s the world we live in.”

“It’s a different world. Men don’t know what they’re supposed to do for women anymore.”

But men can counteract the stance taken by women not through frustration or retaliation, but by re-strategizing.  They should change their thinking by viewing their identity and purpose as not based on roles. They can adopt a new consciousness of who they are and what determines their manhood, avoiding societal trends to confuse them or influence their understanding of themselves.

“Men therefore need a God-given identity if they are to fulfill their true purpose….Once more, we must realize that when men are ignorant of their true identity, it affects not only their callings and fulfillment, but also that of their families and of society as a whole….I believe if we don’t address the male’s identity crisis, our whole generation is in trouble. There’s no escaping this fact.”

The above was inspired by the book Understanding the Purpose and Power of Men, Dr. Myles Munroe.

All rights reserved 2011.

We want to hear from you! Comment below

YOU MAY LIKE these other articles

When a Man Loves a Woman

Talking About Female Independence and it’s Implications

We Are Not Intimidated by Independent Women

The Independent Woman Backlash

Why are so Many Black Women Single: The Story that Hasn’t Been Told

If you use any of our articles or quote from them, please remember to give us the credit

5 thoughts on “A Crisis of Roles: Understanding the Power and Purpose of Men

  1. Nicely written article. The change in society brought on by women’s lib, the increase in divorce rates and society’s one sided approach to domestic violence i.e. women are victims and men perpetrators of domestic violence, has caused a great deal of confusion for men.
    Over the last several decades more children than ever have grow up in divorced homes with mothers as the head of household and no father/male role models. This, in part, has caused a paradigm shift (some good, some not good) in the way girls and boys view themselves.
    Boys are being lectured on all the things they should not do and girls are told the sky’s the limit, there is nothing they can’t do.
    I wonder are there areas where we have gone to far in the name of equality?

    1. Thanks Jan. We appreciate your support of our work and we support yours. It would be remiss of us (despite the name of the site) to take a one-sided view of issues that relate to both sexes. Our men are indeed in a crisis. They’ve felt the blunt of bashing and rejection and are confused as to their place in a woman’s life and society as a whole. When it comes to society one might say, the more we get the less we have. We should be sensitive to the needs of others while we seek to advance our own needs. Perhaps, Machiavelli was correct when he said, the end justifies the means, or Thomas Hobbes when he wrote of the nature of man as “selfish” amongst other things. We gotta love and respect our men, always, freedom or no freedom, independence or no independence. Of course, throwing domestic violence in the scheme of things changes the argument altogether, everything is relative to circumstances.

  2. cassandra thomas

    i believe that a man”s god given identity is to fulfill their true purpose.Which is to provide and protect,as a father and husband if this role is taken away from him,there is no escaping this crisis

  3. Sam Iso

    Its a nice work here.
    I agree that Men have to look into their true identity.
    And av experienced the saving-Power of Women, they are always @d Fore-Front,they’r most influential, protective and determine.
    It was evident in the creation story…d Serpent met the Woman first!
    Bless you.

  4. I do agree with the beginning of the article where it explains the probelm we face as both men and women. It is all too real. And very much true.

    However, towards the end of the article it says that Men need a, “god-given identity”… Whoa! Hold on there cowgirl!

    Men HAVE been given an identity and this identity has existed since the beginning of time. We are “MEN”, and i feel regardless to who makes more money in the household this needs to be respected and upheld throughout the course of time. Yes, times have changed but just as a student respects his teacher for the knowledge put inside of them…women should also share that respect for it is MAN who has taught her all that she knows in the working world.

    I’m not saying men are superior, or that women need to bow down, etc etc… But i strongly feel that by losing the respect for the role of the man, we are contributing to our own inevtiable self-destruction of the family structure and the sanctity of the family unit. it almost seems that men and women are at war with eachother. I know thats how i feel in my current relationship or lack thereof.

    There is a reason why those who dont over extend themselves are able to progress through all kinds of adversity, such as the economy…etcetc…

    The world needs balance, a family needs balance…we all need balance to form a strong and steady foundation of existance and without it we are doomed to fail.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s